In the wake of the Asiana airplane crash in San Francisco, the question of where the lawsuit should be held naturally arises.

This is important because where the lawsuit is held determines how much victims can potentially receive in damages. If the lawsuit is filed in China, for example the maximum compensation for such an accident would be $65,000 (400,000 Yuan), compared with a $1.5 million minimum in the U.S. To determine venue, we will touch on the Montreal Convention which is the governing treaty to which the U.S., China, and South Korea are a party to. Then, we will touch on the theory of forum nonconveniens which is an argument that Asiana may raise against holding the litigation here in the U.S.

item intro 77 sThe Montreal Convention allows a passenger to sue in a variety of countries as a result of air accidents: (1) the carrier's domicile, (2) the carrier's principal place of business, (3) where the ticket was purchased, (4) the flight's destination, and (5) the passenger's "principal and permanent residence," which is defined as "the one fixed permanent abode of the passenger at the time of the accident." Here, some facts that support litigation in the U.S. are: The South Korean Airline does business in the U.S., the accident occurred in San Francisco, the injured were treated in a U.S. hospital, and sixty four of the passengers are U.S. citizens. However, Asiana may argue some facts that suggest the lawsuit being held in China: The plane tickets were purchased in China, the final destination of the round trip was China, and 141 passengers are Chinese nationals.

Furthermore, Asiana may argue that the case can be more conveniently maintained in China under the theory of forum nonconveniens, which basically means China is a more convenient venue for the litigation. For this, a court must consider the private interests of the litigants and the public interests in determining the convenience of the forum. For private interests, the court looks at the availability of evidence and the location of witnesses among other practical problems that affect the cost of the litigation. For public interests, the court looks at administrative difficulties such as congested dockets, burden of jury duty on the people of a community having little or no connection with the litigation, the desirability of holding a trial near those most affected by it, and the familiarity of the court with the governing law.

Here, the facts suggest against the forum nonconveniens argument. Evidence and witnesses are located here, courts here have experience with the substantive law governing airline accidents, and families of victims may be located here and have a connection with the litigation. Moreover, there is ordinarily a strong presumption in favor of the plaintiff’s choice of forum, and dismissal on the basis of forum nonconveniens is normally used only in exceptional situations.

Testimonials

Disclaimer: Materials on this website have been prepared by Law Offices of Michael Y. Lo for general informational purposes only. They are not legal advice. The transmission and receipt of information, through viewing, printing, e-mail or otherwise, is not intended to create or constitute an attorney-client relationship. Persons should not rely or act upon the information without seeking professional counsel. If these materials are not consistent with the rules governing attorney communications in a particular state, and the materials result in client contact in the state, Law Offices of Michael Y. Lo will not assume the representation of clients from those states. The materials contained herein do not constitute an offer to represent you. These materials may be considered advertising not complying with State Bar requirements in your state. 

Business Hours & Contact

Monday - Friday: 9 AM - 5 PM
Phone: (626) 289.8838

Email: contact@lolollp.com
Main Office

506 North Garfield Ave., Suite 280
Alhambra, CA 91801

Get Directions
Los Angeles Office

515 S. Flower Street, 36th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071

Appointment Only
Glendale Office

655 North Central Avenue, 17th Floor
Glendale, CA 91203

Appointment Only
Diamond Bar Office

1370 Valley Vista Drive, Suite 200
Diamond Bar, CA 91765

Appointment Only
Irvine Office

17901 Von Karman Avenue, Suite 600
Irvine, CA 92614

Appointment Only

LOLO logo white

Proud to provide San Gabriel Valley businesses and residents with expert legal services since 1981.